Reviews and Comments

Jürgen Hubert

juergen_hubert@bookrastinating.com

Joined 3 years ago

I write English-language books about German folklore. I primarily read books about folklore & mythology, history, and tabletop role-playing games.

Mastodon profile: thefolklore.cafe/@juergen_hubert

This link opens in a pop-up window

Heide Göttner-Abendroth: Frau Holle - Das Feenvolk der Dolomiten (Paperback, Helmer Ulrike) No rating

Ich hatte diese Buch auf meine Wunschliste geschickt, weil ich mehr über den Frau Holle/Hulda/Perchta-Mythos herausfinden wollte - was ein wichtiges Element der deutschsprachigen Sagen und Legenden ist.

Aber jetzt wo ich es in den Händen halte, scheint es sich bei dem Buch eher um eine literarische Neuverfassung der Hulda-Mythologie als eine wissenschaftliche Arbeit zu sein. Was an sich nichts falsches ist, aber es hilft mir bei meinen eigenen Recherchen nur bedingt weiter. Ich erkenne zwar viele Elemente der Geschichten wieder, aber es gibt keine Quellenangaben, die mir sagen, wo diese herkommen.

Falls jemand andere gute Werke über den Hulda-Mythos kennt, dann lasst es mich wissen!

Dario Spada: Gnomi, fate, folletti e altri esseri fatati in Italia (Italian language, 1989, SugarCo) No rating

When reading Italian-language books, my progress is still very slow. For one thing, I am still a beginner (I've had two years' worth of evening classes so far). For another, I take note of any words I don't know yet and write them down on index cards for further memorization.

Still, I managed to finish the Introduction ("Introduzione") this morning, so soon I will begin with the actual entries of folkloric creatures...

Dario Spada: Gnomi, fate, folletti e altri esseri fatati in Italia (Italian language, 1989, SugarCo) No rating

I am trying to learn Italian, I am trying to expand my knowledge of folklore, so this encyclopedia of Italian "Gnomes, Fairies, and Kobolds" was an obvious choice for me.

Heiner Boehncke, Hans Sarkowicz: Die Deutschen Räuberbanden (German language, 1991, Eichborn) No rating

Da hatte ich in einem öffentlichen Bücherschrank einen echten Glücksgriff. Irgendwann will ich mal ein Buch über Sagen und Legenden zum Thema "Räuber und Gesetzlose" schreiben, und solche Sekundärliteratur kommt mir da gerade recht.

Richard Kühnau: Schlesische Sagen 3 - Zauber-, Wunder- und Schatzsagen (1913, B.G. Teubner)

An excellent conclusion to a great series!

The third volume of Kühnau's massive collection of Silesian folk tales focuses on tales of "magic, miracles, and treasures", and it fully delivers. All tales are neatly arranged by topic, starting with tales of witches and witchcraft, and ending with tales of miners and my personal favorite the "Wahles" - or, as I like to call them, "Ultraterrestrial Venetians". Furthermore, each tale clearly lists its source, which is sadly not something that should be taken for granted with folk tale collections - but it is greatly appreciated by researchers like me.

Kühnau erred on the side of comprehensiveness, which means that many of the tales will start feeling a bit repetitive the longer each chapter goes on. But that, too, is something that works in my favor, since I can pick the best variants for further translation.

All in all, this public domain work - which is available …

Harald Busch, Gottfried Edelmann: Griechische Kunst: Monumente Alter Kulturen (1967, Umschau Verlag) No rating

Der ewige Kampf:

"Ich sollte keine Bücher mehr von öffentlichen Bücherschränken mitnehmen - ich habe sowieso zu viele Bücher!"

vs.

"Hey, eine elfbändige Bildbandserie über Kunst aus verschiedenen Epochen und Kulturen!"

Alexander Schöppner: Sagenbuch der bayerischen Lande. Erster Band (German language, 1852, M. Rieger) No rating

This book has far too many poems for my liking - they are far too much of a hassle for me to translate. However, they are easily skippable.

Other than that, a major focus of the folk tales in this book seem to be religious stories - the founding of churches and monasteries, stories behind church ornaments and relics, and so forth. I'm not sure if this is was the planned focus for the first book in this series (there are two further volumes), or if this continues throughout of the collection.

I could easily fill an entire book with tales about churches and monasteries from all over Germany. However, I'm not sure how popular such a collection would be - presumably, most fans of folk tales are more interested in tales of supernatural creatures, magic and the like. Thus, it's probably best if I tackle this kind …

Martin Beheim Schwarzbach: Rittersagen (Hardcover, Wirtschaftsverlag Ueberreuter) No rating

There are an awful lot of German folk tale collections which focus on "heroic knights".

Which only makes me more motivated to publish a folk tale collection focusing on wicked nobles as an antidote.

commented on Don Camillo by Giovannino Guareschi (I romanzi di Don Camillo)

Giovannino Guareschi: Don Camillo (Paperback, Italiano language, 2017, Rizzoli) No rating

Il mondo della Bassa, irruente e sanguigno, e i due protagonisti, il parroco don Camillo …

Content warning On "Prima storia"