Reviews and Comments

The Shining Kingdoms supplement for the Pathfinder setting of Golarion details the southeastern reaches of the continent of Avistan.

First, let's get the bad news out of the way: This book has a writeup of Andoran. For those of you who are unfamiliar with the setting, Andoran is basically a fantasy counterpart of "The United States of America, as portrayed in propaganda about the War of Independence and World War II" - as opposed to how the USA actually were at the time. Complete with Eagle Knights spreading "FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY(TM)" around the world. This was a bad concept when the setting was first published, and while the authors did their best, there is only so much you can do to improve such a premise. I suppose this makes for a fine setting for those who can look beyond the premise (especially with the conflict of Cheliax heating up), but I am not among their number.

In contrast, my unexpected favorite was Druma. I knew little of this region going in, other than that it was some kind of merchant oligarchy, and did not have high expectations. But the philosophy/religion of the "Prophets of Kalistrade", their behavioral codex, their aesthetics, and their personalized afterlives make them rather fantastic than real world oligarchies. Don't get me wrong - the folks calling the shots here are still pretty selfish and evil people, but I appreciate their difference for the sake of fantasy escapism. And I could imagine an awesome campaign set in Druma where the PCs try to fight the rising influence of the Whispering Tyrant - and the Prophets are worse than useless, as they are either in denial about the threat, or have to face an enemy for the first time whom they cannot bribe.

The first of the two non-human realms in this book is the Five Kings Mountains, the heart of dwarven culture on Golarion. The realm is very dwarfish, with all that implies, but it also has enough fodder for a long-term campaign - with the return of an ancient dragon and his assorted minions, cultists of Droskar plotting in the shadows, and the usual dangers of the Darklands emerging from the depth, there is enough for adventurers to do even without venturing into the regional politics of the larger area. I haven't read the associated Highhelm sourcebook and the Sky King's Tomb Adventure Paths yet, but I am looking forward to what I find. I also like the inclusion of a gazeteer to Larrad, a dwarven city that functions as a pilgrimage site - dwarven spirituality is an interesting subject, and this site gives us some fascinating glimpses into it.

Galt has moved on from its eternal repeated "French Revolutions", and in my opinion this makes for a better setting. If everything you have done to build a better nation is simply swept away by the next revolution, then that's the point? Now the actions of the player characters actually have a chance to make the region better - but at the same time, this chapter emphasizes how fragile the new "post-revolutionary" order is. Adventuring parties active in this country will have plenty to do thanks to the numerous dirty secrets hidden away by the chaos of the past. At the same time, they need to hone their diplomatic skills so that their actions and revelations don't cause a return to the Bad Old Days.

Kyonin is the second non-human realm - the heart of elven culture on Golarion. It is just as elvish as the Five Kinds Mountains are dwarvish. But although the writeup emphasizes that the realm is opening up and is more welcoming to non-elven visitors, I judge it to be not as viable for a long-term campaign as the dwarven realm. The main threat within Kyonin are the demonic remnants in Tanglebriar, now that Treerazer is gone, and although this works well for a series of adventure, in my view that's not enough for an entire campaign. There are some intrigues among the elves, but these aren't likely to become violent unless something goes deeply wrong. This chapter is still useful, but I see this realm as more of a home base for elven adventurers or an interlude from adventures in other parts of the Shining Kingdoms than the whole setting for a game. Though if you need to have the equivalent of Elrond's Council against the Dark Lord (i.e. the Whispering Tyrant), this is the place for it.

Finally, Taldor is the local equivalent of Earth's Byzantine Empire - if it had survived its collapse as a much smaller and less influential nation. Overall, I found its portrayal to be a somewhat mixed bag. According to the timeline, Taldor is more than 6,000 years old, exceeding that of any realm on Earth, yet that massive age isn't as present in its geographic description as I would have preferred. You feel the weight of history in the capital Oppara, yet the regions don't feel substatially different from other fantasy nations a tenth their age. Much of the country should be littered with monuments of its past glories, when its armies and fleets plundered vast swathes of Avistan and beyond.

But despite my misgivings about some aspects of this book, it is still a worthy addition to my library of books about Golarion - and the Shining Kingdoms are worth a visit for your adventurers, too.

#ttrpg #Pathfinder #Golarion

My main complaint about this book is that it is too short. But then again, how could it be otherwise?

This book covers Tian Xia, an entire continent for #Golarion , the "default" campaign setting for the #Pathfinder #TTRPG . Just like the default "Inner Sea" region is vaguely inspired by Europe and North Africa, so is Tian Xia inspired by Asia, and does its best to make it an interesting region to play in. But Tian Xia is several thousands of miles in diameter, and this book has a mere 302 - and thus, each region and country on this continent will only get the briefest of oversights. Which for a detail-oriented setting junkie like me is frustrating, to say the least.

The authors of the various regional writeups did try to make the most out of their word count. We get a decent idea of what the local culture is like, and most regions have some good conflicts and other hooks for adventures and even entire campaigns around. However, there is a dearth of locations - each region is several hundreds of miles in diameter, but we only get three to four (briefly) described locations for each region. A GM who wants to run a campaign in one of these regions will have to do a lot of worldbuilding - which is not something I personally abhor, but if you plan to use this setting, then this is something you should keep in mind. I do hope that some of the authors of this work will publish more in-depth regional gazetteers using the Pathfinder Infinite Community Title program if Paizo doesn't support this setting further directly.

(Speaking of worldbuilding - is there a list somewhere of which real world culture inspired which region in Tian Xia? With some regions it was obvious even for me, but with others I would have to do some further research.)

Apart from the brevity, there were only a few parts of this book I wasn't fond of:

• Linvarre: A nation founded by "Western" colonizers who were welcomed as stabilizing force does not sit well with me, although I realize that this is a holdover from a previous edition where the editorial decisions were... less wise.
• The arcade games games in Goka, which were too anachronistic for my tastes.
• Quain: I don't mind martial arts as such, and have played a monk in my time, but a nation focused this much on martial arts is a bit over-the-top for my tastes. Other people's tastes might differ.

On the other hand, there were some real highlights:

• Po Li: Its worship of a vanished ruler is delightfully creep. "Trust the Eternal Emperor! The Eternal Emperor is your Friend!"...
• Tianjing: You could run an entire campaign focusing on preventing this land from becoming another Worldwound... or letting it happen and then have another campaign about containing it again.
• Kwanlai: I do love a good "underdog" tale.

To sum it up, I would strongly recommend this book to anyone who wants to run fantasy campaigns in an Asian-themed setting, and I hope this work will not be the end of the support for this region.

The next #Golarion setting book I have decided to read after the "Tian Xia World Guide".

Will I be able to stomach the #Andoran writeup? Only time will tell!

#Pathfinder #ttrpg

This work contains player-facing options for Tian Xia, the "Asian"-themed continent of Pathfinder's Golarion setting. A huge part of the book discusses different ancestries. Some are variant takes on existing ancestries, such as kobolds, goblins, leshies, and so forth. Others are new to this volume. The kitsune were to be expected. Tanuki are a bit more obscure, although still fairly recognizable. But the more obscure ones stand out - my favorites are tsukumogami poppets, old items whose spirits have awakened to sentience.

Another major chapter is on archetypes, many of which are tied to local arts and crafts. In such cases, their section have copious notes on these crafts, which will help the players and GMs to understand their cultural significance. However, a word of caution - there are some archetypes which can drastically shift the tone of a game. The most blatant of these is the Starlit Sentinel - yes, now you too can play a Magical Girl/Boy right out of anime in Pathfinder 2E. GMs should be ready to either enforce archetype rarity classifications, or face the consequences.

All in all, this book whetted my appetite for its companion piece, the Tian Xia World Guide.