Fernando reviewed Elantris by Brandon Sanderson
Una obra maestra
Dejo mi reseña en www.enredandotemas.com/2023/06/descubriendo-la-magia-de-de-brandon.html
Hardcover, 492 pages
English language
Published May 1, 2005 by Tor.
Once the godlike rulers of the capital of Arelon, the inhabitans of Elantris have been imprisoned within themselves, unable to die after the city's magic failed years ago. But when a new prince falls victim to the curse, he refuses to accept his fate.
Dejo mi reseña en www.enredandotemas.com/2023/06/descubriendo-la-magia-de-de-brandon.html
Really surprising book. It may not get a lot of headlines vs Sandersons other books, but should. One of his best.
"Elantris" me ha dejado una impresión duradera. Me cautivó el rico escenario creado por Sanderson, donde los detalles sobre los distintos reinos, facciones y grupos religiosos se presentan de manera puntual pero continua. Agradezco que el autor no dedique largas descripciones a estos aspectos, sino que los introduzca naturalmente a través de los diálogos entre los personajes. Dejo mi reseña en : www.enredandotemas.com/2023/06/descubriendo-la-magia-de-de-brandon.html
This is a very nice, fun read. Compared to his later works, it's clear that Sanderson has grown a lot. The characters here are good, the plot decent, and the setting great, but over the years Sanderson has matured his style a lot and perfected his art. This is still nevertheless, a great read for those looking for a short dive into a fantastical world and are willing to forgive a few rough parts here and there.
For a full review, check out my blog: strakul.blogspot.com/2022/03/book-review-elantris-by-brandon.html
Awesome novel, as usual for Sanderson, but it shows its immaturity relative to later books in the Cosmere. More than anything else, the time frame of the events feels a bit weird. Still, an amazing book both in and of itself, and considering it was his first published one! :D
Although, for me at least, is the worst of Sanderson's books so far. It is still a masterpiece, and it is still between my top 15 favourite books. This is indeed a show of just how good is Brandon
Wonderful character-building. I really cared about some of the characters.
I also appreciated that the book, while open to sequels, could stand on its own. So many questions were answered, and I felt like every loose end and foreshadowed idea came to fruition in some way or another.
Not my favorite Sanderson but a strong book none the less. It was a surprising read, strong characters, and good story. But you can definitely tell how much Sanderson has grown as an author from this book.
3.5 stars. This is Brandon Sanderson's first novel, and it shows. It contains all the elements that make him so extraordinary now: worldbuilding, unique magic system, and political struggles. Just on a lesser skilled frame than Mistborn or The Way of Kings.
Elantris is a city in the country of Arelon. Ten years ago before the story happened, a natural disaster caused magic to fail in the city. Before that day, the Reod, the inhabitants of Elantris had been god-like creatures with magic powers who were able to create food from dirt, heal wounds and live like gods, with the country of Arelon serving them. But not anymore. Elantris is now full of zombie-like creatures without any magic or life in them. It is into this city that the protagonist Prince Raoden, crown-prince of Arelon, gets tossed in when his body begins the transformation to Elantrian and he joins the …
3.5 stars. This is Brandon Sanderson's first novel, and it shows. It contains all the elements that make him so extraordinary now: worldbuilding, unique magic system, and political struggles. Just on a lesser skilled frame than Mistborn or The Way of Kings.
Elantris is a city in the country of Arelon. Ten years ago before the story happened, a natural disaster caused magic to fail in the city. Before that day, the Reod, the inhabitants of Elantris had been god-like creatures with magic powers who were able to create food from dirt, heal wounds and live like gods, with the country of Arelon serving them. But not anymore. Elantris is now full of zombie-like creatures without any magic or life in them. It is into this city that the protagonist Prince Raoden, crown-prince of Arelon, gets tossed in when his body begins the transformation to Elantrian and he joins the 'zombie' masses. At the same time, his fiancee Princess Sarene arrives in Arelon, only to find out that her husband-to-be 'died' and she is now legally tied to be a widow and member of the royal family. A royal family that is not very stable in its rule, and which is threatened when Gyorn Hrathen arrives in Arelon, trying to convert the country to his god Shu-Dereth for the Empire of Fjorden.
I don't know, sometimes I was really thrown off by this book. It is written in what felt like a very light-hearted manner but the story that is going on itself is not very light-hearted at all. Those are desperate times in Arelon and Elantris, and I never really get to feel that despair inbetween all the light-hearted banter of Sarene and her band of Arelene nobles. The emotional impact could have been a lot higher, which would have made this a lot better. I think it's in this area that Sanderson has grown the most, if I compare Elantris to The Way of Kings, e.g. Sarene seemed like a first prototype version of Shallan in TWoK. Or maybe he just likes to write about women like that. Female characterisation is not a huge strength of his for me, I tend to like his male characters a lot better.
That said, despite this grudge of mine, the book is chock-full of action, and especially the last 20% are full of surprises, twists, turns and kept me glued to my Kindle.
I had hoped to get a better understanding of Sanderson's Cosmere universe from reading this, but other than spotting Hoid in the book, I am still no further at grasping what connects all his worlds.