With a new preface, afterword, and updated material throughout, this iconoclastic and creative Tibetan meditation …
A Generous and Compassionate Wake-Up Call
5 stars
This is probably the most generous attempt to transmit the essence of #Buddhism I've ever encountered. While the choice of framework and some of the references Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse makes place him squarely within the #Tibetan tradition, this is a deeply #ecumenical work which reaches across all #Buddhist lineages and traditions. Will all traditions agree with everything he writes? Probably not, but it would be extremely difficult to be even more inclusive while also writing such a readable book.
What might make the book difficult for some is that he is quite direct about poking holes through a large swath of commonly cherished beliefs throughout. I experienced this as clever and illuminating as I would expect from a skilled skeptic debater, but I imagine that some might not appreciate this as a compassionate ripping-off of the band-aid or revealing pulling-out of the rug as I did.
Bonus points …
This is probably the most generous attempt to transmit the essence of #Buddhism I've ever encountered. While the choice of framework and some of the references Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse makes place him squarely within the #Tibetan tradition, this is a deeply #ecumenical work which reaches across all #Buddhist lineages and traditions. Will all traditions agree with everything he writes? Probably not, but it would be extremely difficult to be even more inclusive while also writing such a readable book.
What might make the book difficult for some is that he is quite direct about poking holes through a large swath of commonly cherished beliefs throughout. I experienced this as clever and illuminating as I would expect from a skilled skeptic debater, but I imagine that some might not appreciate this as a compassionate ripping-off of the band-aid or revealing pulling-out of the rug as I did.
Bonus points to Devendra Banhart for reading the audio version. His calm reading of Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse's writing has the dual effect of making it easier to hear truths which may be difficult to accept while also subtly emphasizing the power and sharpness of Khyentse's rapier wit.
This one is definitely going on my list of books to recommend to the Buddhist-curious or even to those already-practicing #Buddhists who may have a bit more stiffness in their practice than is good for them.
In the face of systemic racism and state-sanctioned violence, how can we metabolize our anger …
Creative, Radical, Challenging
3 stars
It's hard to know what to write about this one.
On the one hand, I experience much of Lama Rod's teaching in this book as brilliantly creative. The meditation instructions are well-systematized and I found the guidance helpful, especially for the #7homecomings, #tonglen, and #EarthTouching / #bhūmisparśa practices. I also deeply appreciated his acknowledgement of the issues present in the #Tibetan#Buddhist tradition and his way of relating to flawed teachers in a system vulnerable to abuse of power was valuable for me. The way he addresses #racism, #whitesupremacy, #queerphobia, #patriarchy and other forms of #discrimination or #opression reminded me favorably of Sebene Selassie'sYou Belong.
On the other, having now listened to it in its entirety, it seems like the book might have put together in a piecemeal sort of way. I get the impression that this might have …
It's hard to know what to write about this one.
On the one hand, I experience much of Lama Rod's teaching in this book as brilliantly creative. The meditation instructions are well-systematized and I found the guidance helpful, especially for the #7homecomings, #tonglen, and #EarthTouching / #bhūmisparśa practices. I also deeply appreciated his acknowledgement of the issues present in the #Tibetan#Buddhist tradition and his way of relating to flawed teachers in a system vulnerable to abuse of power was valuable for me. The way he addresses #racism, #whitesupremacy, #queerphobia, #patriarchy and other forms of #discrimination or #opression reminded me favorably of Sebene Selassie'sYou Belong.
On the other, having now listened to it in its entirety, it seems like the book might have put together in a piecemeal sort of way. I get the impression that this might have been intentional or seen as unproblematic as a way to enhance the sense of authenticity. I listened to the audio version, and while the inclusion of the original audio for the interviews was a nice touch, it felt a lot like recycling content to me—I think I would have preferred a more edited final version with links to the originals for anyone who wanted to dig deeper.
On the whole, it was well worth the time I spent with it. I feel like I've learned quite a bit. If anyone is reading this and trying to decide between the print & audio versions, I would guess that the print version might be a bit easier to use, especially if one intends to refer frequently to the instructions for #meditation and #reflection.