The Tainted Cup

I enjoyed this book and it is worthy of the accolades it has received. I'm usually way behind in my reading and I rarely read a Hugo winner so soon. The world building is superb. Humans are at constant threat from enormous sea creatures who frequently try to burst through gigantic sea walls, bringing physical destruction and strange biological mutations which humans can not survive.

The leviathans are also the source of a sort of biological technology, which plays the role usually filled by magic in this genre.

The narrator, Din, has certain pseudo-magical abilities, but he is also severely dyslexic. His boss, Ana, is seemingly unable to stand too much sensory stimulus, and spends most of her life wearing a blindfold. She is also possessed of brilliant skills of analysis and deduction.

Such diversity is welcome in modern fiction, but it doesn't make a good book on its own. In fact if it's heavy-handed it can ruin a good book. Thankfully, the author handles it deftly. The weird and wonderful traits of his characters, be they surpluses or deficits, blend perfectly with the extraordinarily rich setting he weaves. I greatly enjoyed both the main characters.

Contrasting with the wildly original fantasy world, the format of the plot is a murder mystery, with the brilliant Ana always one step ahead of the other characters and the reader. It is not a format that I particularly enjoy, but there is so much wonder and horror wrapped around it I didn't mind. I willingly, indeed gleefully consume the genre conventions of science fiction and fantasy. I'm not going to be converted to crime and mystery, but the genre mashup in "The Tainted Cup" was a good way to have a taste of those forms.

Mystery fans who don't like fantasy might have a similar pleasure coming at it from the other direction.

This book was a wonderful little murder (and more!) mystery set in a fantasy setting with some very interesting and unique world building. The characters are all extremely compelling, even Ana, who is quite obviously an homage to Sherlock Holmes. Despite that fact, she manages to still stand out as her own true self, not as a cheap imitation, and it's hard not to love her, especially when viewed through the eyes of her assistant.

I highly recommend this book to most!

This book was a wonderful little murder (and more!) mystery set in a fantasy setting with some very interesting and unique world building. The characters are all extremely compelling, even Ana, who is quite obviously an homage to Sherlock Holmes. Despite that fact, she manages to still stand out as her own true self, not as a cheap imitation, and it's hard not to love her, especially when viewed through the eyes of her assistant.

I highly recommend this book to most!

This was a great read. Like Bennett's "City of ..." series, this one mixes mystery with fantasy and again carries off Bennett's skill in creating a page-turner. Describing The Tainted Cup as crossover or hybrid though doesn't do justice to the variety of narrative and thematic elements appearing in the book. I really enjoyed the world-building of Daretana as a society heavily dependent on plant-based materials and biological sciences. The two primary characters, as detectives, were fascinating and in lesser hands I think would have been difficult to pull off. Bennett however makes them relatable and it is fascinating to watch the trajectories of their development through the book. There are also elements of a domestic spy thriller, as Bennett again visits infighting amongst the bureaucratic concerns of states. If that weren't enough, there are Kaiju elements as well.

I don't always feel surprised reading a Bennett book, but the pages fly by and I never feel as though something is unconvincing or poorly rendered. Very much looking forward to the next one.

A political-intrigue mystery drama pursued by a Holmes-and-Watson pair in a speculative Roman-style empire which relies on advanced bio-engineering to fend off a constant flood of Kaiju from the ocean and the contagious bio-horror they bring with them. Which… that might sound like too many concepts to comfortably contain in a story this short, but it all blends together like a perfect smoothie of mystery & adventurous drama — you're simply along for the ride.

I'm reminded of The Affair of the Mysterious Letter, another delightful novel which also uses a Holmes-and-Watson mystery as an excuse to show off wonderful worldbuilding. Perhaps there's a lesson here: if you've invented a weird world but are having trouble fitting a story into it, a Holmes-and-Watson mystery is a great excuse for some characters to wander around all your scenic locales, explaining things to each other and looking closely at all the neat details you want to show off?

This novel absolutely nails it: incredibly fun, readable, & engaging. Nothing wasted, respectful of the reader's time & interest. Absolutely recommended; looking forward to the next installment.

A fantasy murder mystery served with a dollop of Pacific Rim, garnished with a hint of The Goblin Emperor, and a tiny sprig of romance. It was nicely written with interesting world-building and enjoyable characters; Ana, in particular, was a delight. The murder plot and its somewhat deflated resolution kept this at a 3-star rating for me. Though the opportunity is rarely afforded in fantasy whodunits, I like to follow along and solve crimes too! While it didn't guarantee a sequel a place on my to-read list, I might try more from this author.

The Tainted Cup is very much a fantasy Holmes novel, where a labyrinthine mystery is being solved by an almost supernaturally skilled investigator and their lovable but hapless assistant, through whose viewpoint the story is being presented.

The setting is delightfully weird, much more like Divine Cities than Founders, with elements of existential/apocalyptic threat and imperialism.

I'm looking forward to more in this universe.

The Tainted Cup is an amazing fantasy mystery novel (first in a new series) from Robert Jackson Bennett. For what it's worth, I love love loved The Founders trilogy and quite enjoyed The Divine Cities trilogy so I'm coming into this with some bias.

I've seen this pitched as "Sherlock with kaiju", but I think the Sherlock moniker sells it short for me. The Sherlock / Watson dynamic to me is defined by one where Sherlock is the expert observer, deducer, and dilettante and Watson is the bumbling stand-in for the reader (or at best a medical expert). In The Tainted Cup, I think the sleuthing expertise is split between Kol (the assistant investigator) and Ana (the investigator in charge) and this changes the dynamic entirely in a way that makes the mystery more satisfying structurally. Also, I think personality-wise, they are also quite distinct.

Kol, the point of view assistant investigator, has been biologically modified to have eidectic memory. As he can remember anything he sees, it's his job to be the eyes of the investigator (and also the reader)--viewing crime scenes, talking to witnesses, and poking around to try to dig up as much as he can. Ana, the investigator boss has Sherlockian deductive skill, but whose senses are overwhelmed by the world itself and so stays in her office, relying on Kol to see what's important and bring it back for her to synthesize. There's definitely a power and authority hierarchy here, but what works for me is that Kol's observational competence is strong, and it gives a perfect excuse for the reader to see all of the clues.

I felt like I had put together about half of the mystery myself by the end, but there were still quite a few surprises for me. The closure of the mystery is excellent, and is quite satisfying in the way it brings together every small detail that's been slowly spooled out over time (even, of course, the title). All of this places the book solidly in the mystery genre, rather than just "a fantasy with a murder mystery". It's even complete with a couple of "let me gather everybody to lay out my accusations" style scenes.

But it's the worldbuilding that adds color on top of the solid mystery. The fantasy here is that there this world has experts in biological augmentation, where people are changed to further their station in service of the Empire, often in ways that have negative consequences for them personally. Technologically, things feel like an industrial age that has pursued biological advances rather than gas, such as mushrooms for cooling or worms for lighting. The Empire itself comprises a series of ring walls, where every wet season gigantic titans attack from the sea and must be repelled.

I would have happily read either just a great mystery or a fantasy novel with such an interesting world, but having both together was a delight.

I'm interested in the world and the power dynamics, but multiple big points in the mystery portion of the novel were obvious many chapters before they happened. Which isn't a degree of cleverness I normally have for other mysteries. That extends at least a bit to the larger mystery surrounding the leviathans, though I do still want to continue with this series and see how that larger plot ultimately plays out.

Is this book really 432 pages long? Because I raced through it in a day, and it felt like it moved so quickly! I've always been impressed with RJB's world building, but this one might be my favorite yet. What do we call a world where plants provide light, vines are cultivated to be deadly security systems, the rich can afford large mushrooms that regulate the air temperature, and the murder weapon is a tree? Ugh, I love it. There are also strong notes of the usual "big monsters threaten humanity" suspects - Pacific Rim, Kaiju No. 8, and most evidently Attack on Titan, but this story chooses to move the first responders into the background and spend more time on infrastructure folks and a detective/assistant pair.

And what a stunning pair they are. Fans of the eccentric detective+earnest put-upon assistant, get ready to enjoy yourselves. Ana is a genius in all rights, but never in too much of a magical way that it seems she arrived at her conclusions unfairly. The clues are always available, and I did manage to pick out a couple reveals before they were dropped. As our POV character, Din is easily my favorite - his dedication to justice makes him very easy to cheer for, and I appreciated that he wasn't portrayed as completely brainless.

Despite all the giant monsters attacking in the background, this is a mystery first and foremost, and I appreciate that the narrative commits to this. I suspect that the mystery and the background plot will eventually merge in future books, but for now, I was happy just to read a really solid mystery with some great twists, and a really cool detective.

Thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group for an advance copy. All thoughts in this review are my own!