User Profile

liliacea

liliacea@bookrastinating.com

Joined 10 months, 4 weeks ago

Mostly reading in German and English. Languages I am trying to learn/improve: French, Russian, Spanish

Interested in climate and ecology, philosophy, science-fiction and poetry. And a lot else.

Mastodon: liliacea@climatejustice.social

This link opens in a pop-up window

2026 Reading Goal

25% complete! liliacea has read 3 of 12 books.

Amitav Ghosh: The Great Derangement (Hardcover, 2016, University of Chicago Press)

"Are we deranged? The acclaimed Indian novelist Amitav Ghosh argues that future generations may well …

The Great Derangement

This was very interesting to read and definitely gave me a lot to think about. I liked the focus on how fiction is unable to speak about the climate crisis meaningfully, and the emphasis on power relations (and disparities) apart from pure economical ones, later on. The comparison between the texts of the Paris Agreement and Pope Francis's Laudato Si was genius.

Amitav Ghosh: The Great Derangement (Hardcover, 2016, University of Chicago Press)

"Are we deranged? The acclaimed Indian novelist Amitav Ghosh argues that future generations may well …

The fact is that we live in a world that has been profoundly shaped by empire and its disparities. Differentials of power between and within nations are probably greater today than they have ever been. These differentials are, in turn, closely related to carbon emissions. The distribution of power in the world therefore lies at the core of the climate crisis. This is indeed one of the greatest obstacles to mitigatory action, and all the more so because it remains largely unacknowledged. This question will probably be even more difficult to resolve than economic disparities and matters like compensation, carbon budgets, and so on. We do at least possess a vocabulary for economic issues; within the current system of international relations, there is no language in which questions related to the equitable distribution of power can be openly and frankly addressed.

It is for these reasons that I differ with those who identify capitalism as the principal fault line on the landscape of climate change. It seems to me that this landscape is riven by two interconnected but equally important rifts, each of which follows a trajectory of its own: these are capitalism and empire (the latter being understood as an aspiration to dominance on the part of some of the most important structures of the world's most powerful states). In short, even if capitalism were to be magically transformed tomorrow, the imperatives of political and military dominance would remain a significant obstacle to progress on mitigatory action.

The Great Derangement by  (Page 146)

Amitav Ghosh: The Great Derangement (Hardcover, 2016, University of Chicago Press)

"Are we deranged? The acclaimed Indian novelist Amitav Ghosh argues that future generations may well …

From this perspective, global inaction on climate change is by no means the result of confusion or denialism or a lack of planning: to the contrary, the maintenance of the status quo is the plan. Climate change may itself facilitate the realization of this plan by providing an alibi for ever-greater military intrusion into every kind of geographic and military space. And it is quite likely that this plan commands widespread but tacit support in many Western countries. Significant sections of the electorate probably understand that climate change negotiations may have the effect of changing their country's standing in the world's hierarchies of power as well as wealth: this may indeed form the basis of their resistance to climate science in general.

The Great Derangement by  (Page 145)

Carl Cassegård, Håkan Thörn: Post-Apocalyptic Environmentalism (Hardcover, 2022, palgrave macmillan)

How to act when global catastrophe cannot be averted?

This was a very nice read! The book presents a useful framework of three meta-narratives present in environmentalism: green progress, the apocalyptic, and the post-apocalyptic narrative. I found the respective characterizations to be insightful. The relelvance of emotions like grief and anger is mentioned, but might be a little underdeveloped, and I would have liked to read about the role of shame and guilt as well. The concluding remarks about the future and the utopian vision needed were maybe a bit too brief. Still, a very nice, well-researched and well-written book. I especially liked the focus on how hope is not the only motivating force towards climate action and how a post-apocalyptic reckoning with the catastrophe need not be a passivizing or depoliticizing narrative!

Carl Cassegård, Håkan Thörn: Post-Apocalyptic Environmentalism (Hardcover, 2022, palgrave macmillan)

We would be shooting ourselves in the foot if we were to claim that socialism would only be possible in affluent societies. That would make us helpless against climate barbarism. As catastrophes multiply and intensify, such barbarism may well gain ground. To us, climate barbarism is not just about outright xenophobia and eco-fascism, but stands for all action undertaken to preserve privilege in the face of climate change.

Post-Apocalyptic Environmentalism by , (Page 130)

Carl Cassegård, Håkan Thörn: Post-Apocalyptic Environmentalism (Hardcover, 2022, palgrave macmillan)

We support a movement which, firstly, clearly recognizes the role played by industrial capitalism in creating today's environmental problems and aims for a revolutionary transformation of the economy. Secondly, this movement also recognizes that there is nothing automatic about this transformation, which presupposes political struggle. Thirdly, it acknowledges that the catastrophes are already here, and that the fight is therefore not only about preventing future catastrophes, but also about justice for the human and non-human victims who have already been affected.

Post-Apocalyptic Environmentalism by , (Page 128)

Carl Cassegård, Håkan Thörn: Post-Apocalyptic Environmentalism (Hardcover, 2022, palgrave macmillan)

Our suggestion is that the environmental movement - like so many other social movements fighting the ills of capitalism - has failed not only because capitalism has been an overpowering historical force, but also because capitalism has fundamentally shaped the movement, its social base, ideas, and strategies of action. Capitalism does not just involve the exploitation of natural resources; it shapes how we in modern society think about, and organize, the relationship between society and nature.

Post-Apocalyptic Environmentalism by , (Page 114)

Alma Rogge: Die Rosenuhr (Hardcover, 1984, Carl Schünemann)

Wer versteht die Sprache des Windes, wenn er raunt in den Erlenbüschen am Ufer, aufseufzt in den schlanken Halmen des Schilfs, träumerisch murmelt in den alten Weiden? Die große Orgel spielt er zwischen Himmel und Erde, jubelt seine hohen Melodien, tönt in vollschwingenden Akkorden, dunkel klagt er in stürmischen Nächten. Er kommt aus der Ferne, aus der auch unsere Träume kommen, er geht in die Ferne, in der sie verwehn. Er rührt uns auf, wie er das Meer aufwühlt, er bedrängt unser Denken, wie er die Bäume bedrängt. In uns rauscht sein Rauschen, seufzt sein Seufzen, in seinem Sausen zieht unsere Sehnsucht hin. Unser Herz singt im Wind.

Die Rosenuhr by  (Page 65)