Reviews and Comments

Robin Shipton 📚

robinshipton@bookrastinating.com

Joined 3 years ago

Reader and (now) writer of #sciencefiction, #fantasy, and #romance, with a smattering of all kinds of other stuff: #history, #polyamory, #WritingCraft, #philosophy, and #TTRPG books.

Mildly #queer, #TransRights supporter, #parent, and #Canadian. #AntiRacism is a process not a checkbox.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Tim Pratt: The Wrong Stars (Paperback, 2017, Angry Robot)

A ragtag space crew discovers alien technology that could change the fate of humanity—or awaken …

A lot of protagonist-centred sci-fi written for YA and YA+ audiences can be sloppy about characterization and world-building. Happily, The Wrong Stars doesn’t fall into that trap. We get romance and a solid protagonist competence-fantasy, but without the maundering inside or outside of her head that’s such a common pitfall.

A solid read, a satisfying adventure tale, a relationship I cheered and feared for, and an intriguing setting with intrinsic stakes I care about. It makes me want to continue the series to find out what happens next. A success by any measure.

Howard Waldrop: Dream Factories and Radio Pictures (EBook, 2022) No rating

What if the post-apocalyptic world was inherited by the android avatars of a famous duck, …

Florida vs. Disney lead to a chatroom about politics, offhand predictions that Disney would outlive us all, and then a mention of “Heirs of the Perisphere”—a short story about the last Tokyo Disney Resort animatronics in the far post-apocalypse searching for the remains of humanity—by Howard Waldrop, an accomplished author I'd somehow never heard of. So here we are. Gawrsh.

Alessandro Piroddi, Luca Maiorani: Fantasy World (EBook, 2023, MS Edizioni) No rating

Fantasy World is about facing danger, exploring meaningful relationships, traveling to fantastic places and facing …

Not entirely happy with this game. Very inconsistent tone, maybe partly to blame on the translation, and tone is so important in a PbtA game to make the marriage of fiction and function work right. A lot of questionable word choice in the translation too, but the underlying text is often wordy and talks around an idea instead of expressing it concisely.

Not at all impressed by “magically twisted = ugly = evil” being the central tension of one class. The design is good in a lot of the rules, but the class Moves feel like the weakest part.

Beatrix Potter: Short Fiction (EBook, 2023, Standard Ebooks) No rating

A collection of Beatrix Potter’s short stories for children, ordered by date of publication.

…

Each story adds to a strange, self-referential world of animals that are an odd mix of people and animals—young pigs wear coats and are warned about being bought for bacon, kittens are put in Sunday best while running around on four feet, mice make dresses from cloth scraps and keep city manners while other mice go naked without comment. Endearing, a little weird… and very of its time.

Tamsyn Muir: The Mysterious Study of Doctor Sex (EBook, 2020, Tor.com)

A short story by Tamsyn Muir that takes place prior to the events in her …

That was fun.

This really should be listed as 1.5 in the series, not 0.5. I think that's a Goodreads librarian error. Though it's young Cam and Palamedes, it's being written/related by Camilla after the events of Gideon the Ninth.

Brandon Sanderson: Tress of the Emerald Sea (EBook, 2023, Dragonsteel Entertainment, LLC)

The only life Tress has known on her island home in an emerald-green ocean has …

Content warning Very mild spoilers for Huck, seas, and cups. It's only 17% in after all.