Reviews and Comments

Tom - Bookrastinating

farmertre@bookrastinating.com

Joined 3 years, 6 months ago

I read a book or two... when I get to it.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Mike Duncan: The Storm Before the Storm : The Beginning of the End of the Roman Republic (2018)

The Rowdy Republic #bookreview

I loved Mike’s History of Rome podcast but it focuses heavily on the Imperial period. This text zooms in on the turbulent final centuries of the Republic and is a lovely treatment of it. It is a swirl of names and events all threaded expertly by the author.

Brenda Wineapple: The Impeachers (Paperback, 2020, Random House Trade Paperbacks)

When Abraham Lincoln was assassinated and Vice-President Andrew Johnson became “the Accidental President,” it was …

How not to succeed in impeaching and convicting a sociopathic president.

A good pop history of the personalities and events surrounding the impeachment of Andy "The Accident" Johnson and his ultimate acquittal at the first ever presidential impeachment trial. I definitely learned things I did not know regarding the reasons why he was impeached in the first place. His behavior was worse than I knew (and I knew a lot previously) but they impeached on a technicality. Like putting Capone up for tax evasion. Lesson observed... don't nominate a Veep just for votes if they're a sociopath.

U. S. Grant Sharp: Strategy for defeat (1978, Presidio Press)

A former Commander in Chief during the Vietnam War examines official documents, dispatches, and high-level …

CINCPAC talks failures in Vietnam

An easy read, only 271 pages of actual narrative. I recommend it to folks interested in Vietnam war history, and history of air power in war in general.

Always interesting to hear "from the horse's mouth" so to speak. Admiral Ulysses Simpson Grant Sharp Jr. (grand-nephew of his namesake the President and Civil War General) brings forward a first person tale about how the civilian and military leadership of the US fought the war in Vietnam. He was the Commander in Chief of all US forces in the Pacific and served from 64-68 in that role.

Most history I've encountered of this period focuses on the life of the fighting men (mostly men then) and less on the strategic context. The Admiral puts you in the chain of command between Secretary McNamara and the combat forces in theater and discusses his view as the conflict progressed. The crux …

Fergus M. Bordewich: Congress at War (Paperback, Knopf)

This brilliantly argued new perspective on the Civil War overturns the popular conception that Abraham …

Civil War as viewed from Capitol hill

I recommend it. Much of the pop history written about the Civil War focuses on battles and generals, but the story about how Congress fought the war is just as compelling. Bordewich builds the story into a narrative that weaves seamlessly with the external events driving the country and the war. From the secession crisis to the Impeachment of Johnson it's quite a tale.

You really get to know some of the main characters of the age: Pitt Fessenden, Thaddeus Stevens, Benjamin Franklin Wade, et al. Lincoln gets a lot of the limelight in other texts, but the Congress had to keep the lights on and figure out how to function as well as push the nation forward.

reviewed Long Game by Rush Doshi

Rush Doshi: Long Game (2021, Oxford University Press, Incorporated)

Good US/PRC primer

This text attempts to encapsulate the United States relationship and competition with the People’s Republic of China. It uses all kinds of authoritative texts as sources. I am often one who wishes to read primary sources, but in this case, I think the reader benefits significantly from being able to have all of these primary sources summarized. Anybody looking for a pretty thorough analysis of the competition between these two nations historically and extrapolations about the future would do well to read it.

K. Chess: Famous Men Who Never Lived (2021, Tin House Books, LLC)

A work of multiverse art. Amazing debut novel

Content warning I talk about the plot a bit... nothing outlandishly spoiling

Richard McGregor: The Party (2012)

"with Chinese characteristics"

Although not quoted directly in this text, Art 1 Sec 1 of the Constitution of the PRC weighs heavily over this text. "The leadership of the Communist Party of China is the defining feature of socialism with Chinese characteristics. "

This is a great primer for the way the party/state/economy of China functions and how the party maintains that "leadership" across the years.

William Manchester: The Death of a President (Hardcover, 1967, Harper and Row)

Review of: The Death of a President

This text is a hyper detailed accounting of the events of the assassination of JFK and the days before & after. I was transported... and consequently I feel as though I can now share in some of the original emotion and shock of the world at this tragedy.

One of the great things about the text is the diagrams of the key locations which help you build a firmer mental picture of the events.

Mary Beard: SPQR (2015, Liveright Publishing Corporation)

A history of the first millennium of the Roman Empire.

1000 years in the blink of an eye

Dr. Mary Beard ( DBE, FSA, FBA, FRSL) brings together in this small volume an immense amount of history. I have been exposed to a fair amount of Roman history in dribs and drabs over the years, but this narrative brings it all together from what we know of the kings, through the republic and empire until the 1.0 version of the empire created by Octavian ceased to be what it once was after a dozen first citizens.

My favorite piece of this is the up to date (to 2015) scholarship and archeology and what it tells us about the everyday human beings who lived in that world. A pleasure to consume

Nikole Hannah-Jones, The New York Times Company: The 1619 Project (Hardcover, 2021, One World)

In late August 1619, a ship arrived in the British colony of Virginia bearing a …

Know better; do better

Angelou's quote about knowledge and action that I borrowed for the title of this review was not quoted during this text, (as far as I can recall) however it was on the top of my mind throughout my reading of it. Part of being able to make a just society is to educate the ignorant portions of that society to the the injustices inherent in it. This text does that. My own ignorance of the depth of inequality in the US, established and perpetuated by the self interest of the powerful as expressed through racist policy was vast. This compilation of great work inspires me to dig deeper, and to do more.