Reviews and Comments

Amanda

amanda@bookrastinating.com

Joined 3 years, 2 months ago

This link opens in a pop-up window

reviewed Careless People by Sarah Wynn-Williams

Sarah Wynn-Williams: Careless People (AudiobookFormat, 2025, Pan Macmillan)

From trips on private jets and encounters with world leaders to shocking accounts of misogyny …

You are not a good person, you know. Good persons don’t end up here.

This book goes on the record with lots of things we’ve all guessed. I think it will be a crucial source text for history and it does give a glimpse into how the monsters behind Facebook became as they are and of the corrosive effects of hyper wealth on people. What strikes me about Mark and Sheryl as presented through Sarah’s eyes in the book is how human they seem. Reading it, I realise me I’d probably end up a lot like them under similar circumstances. In a way that’s nice because it means evil is a function of systems, not people, at least not primarily.

I also had to fast-forward some of the exhausting humble brags, not to mention some of the MaTeRnAl InStInCtS part, in which Sarah very clearly used the good/mother/nature vs bad/corporate/tech divide for narrative effect. Since I’m reading this as an audiobook while parenting …

Mattie Lubchansky: Simplicity (Hardcover, 2025, Penguin Random House)

Publisher copy:

From the acclaimed author of horror sensation Boys Weekend, a vibrant new …

Not bad, but maybe not what I was expecting

This is a nice little graphic novel. I'm kind of bummed out that it wasn't funnier; Mattie is very funny; many of her online cartoons are some of the funniest I've seen. This graphic novel isn't funny, or at least isn't funny in the same way.

I also have trouble reading it as a novel, in particular following it as any kind of story or character arc. It feels a lot like it just...ends.

Markus Harwood-Jones: Really Cute People (2024, Harlequin Enterprises ULC)

A buzzfeed quiz from 2013 [book]

This book is laser targeted towards queer millennials. I say this as a queer millennial who used to live in a destabilising collective not entirely dissimilar to the one described at the start of the book. The book makes excruciatingly dense reference to eg avocado toast sandwiches and all the rest of it. It’s entire tone is very buzzfeed quiz which quirky queer are you and for some reason it references some of those DIY space heaters a lot. Like, almost as an ad a lot.

I guess I’m supposed to feel pandered to, but I don’t. I just feel exhausted.