AvonVilla@ramblingreaders.org reviewed The Rose Field by Philip Pullman (The Book of Dust)
A lot to take in
5 stars
It's my habit to record my reactions to books I read. I do it here under the heading "review", which implies I will describe whether the book is any good or not.
Mainly I have to say, yes, the book is very good indeed. It is long and gripping and full of all the wonders and unique inventiveness that Philip Pullman has dished up in the five preceding novels in this series. This final book does indeed have the feeling of a major literary event, or a literary big bang as I saw it described in a newspaper article last week. "The Book of Dust" is on track to be as important and well-loved as "His Dark Materials".
In the battle between good and evil that Pullman outlines, there are various forces which represent the two sides. The bonds between humans and the power of the imagination are …
It's my habit to record my reactions to books I read. I do it here under the heading "review", which implies I will describe whether the book is any good or not.
Mainly I have to say, yes, the book is very good indeed. It is long and gripping and full of all the wonders and unique inventiveness that Philip Pullman has dished up in the five preceding novels in this series. This final book does indeed have the feeling of a major literary event, or a literary big bang as I saw it described in a newspaper article last week. "The Book of Dust" is on track to be as important and well-loved as "His Dark Materials".
In the battle between good and evil that Pullman outlines, there are various forces which represent the two sides. The bonds between humans and the power of the imagination are on the good side. A malign force which dissolves those bonds is on the evil side. It incorporates the mindless pursuit of money and the destructive development which is carried out as a result. Initially I found this element of the book to be somewhat mundane, even obvious and simplistic compared to the complexities and mysteries which preceded it. But I agree so strongly with the conclusion that I am prepared to suspend any criticism of Pullman's execution until I've had a chance to contemplate it and re-read it. His great heroine Lyra says it herself, it's complicated and contradictory.
Another misgiving I had was the musing about the nature of consciousness, and the suggestion that it might be a universal field which permeates the universe. I am delighted to see this sort of thing used as a metaphor, less happy at the suggestion that it is to be taken literally. That sounds like religious mumbo jumbo to me. But again, I'll leave my 5 star rating in place until I've had a chance to ponder this more thoroughly. Maybe in future I will edit or rewrite this review. In the meantime, I am happy to say it's a great read, and if you'll forgive the cliche, destined to become a classic.