digital audio
Published 2025 by Macmillan Audio.
Enshittification: It’s not just you—the internet sucks now. It’s been enshittified. That was no accident, and it’s not gonna fix itself. Here’s how we’ll disenshittify it so we can have a new, good internet.
We are all living through the Enshittocene—the Great Enshittening—a time in which the services that matter to us, that we rely on, are being turned into giant piles of shit. It’s frustrating. Demoralizing. Even terrifying.
The once-glorious internet has degenerated into “platforms” that rose to dominance because they delivered convenient and delightful services efficiently and reliably. But once we were locked in to those services, the tech bosses turned on us, relying on our dependency to keep us using the services even as they got worse and worse. The platform bosses did the same to the companies that had flocked to their services to sell stuff to us. Once we were all locked in—businesses …
Enshittification: It’s not just you—the internet sucks now. It’s been enshittified. That was no accident, and it’s not gonna fix itself. Here’s how we’ll disenshittify it so we can have a new, good internet.
We are all living through the Enshittocene—the Great Enshittening—a time in which the services that matter to us, that we rely on, are being turned into giant piles of shit. It’s frustrating. Demoralizing. Even terrifying.
The once-glorious internet has degenerated into “platforms” that rose to dominance because they delivered convenient and delightful services efficiently and reliably. But once we were locked in to those services, the tech bosses turned on us, relying on our dependency to keep us using the services even as they got worse and worse. The platform bosses did the same to the companies that had flocked to their services to sell stuff to us. Once we were all locked in—businesses and users—the tech companies stripped out all utility, save the bare minimum needed to stave off total collapse.
In Enshittification, Cory Doctorow shows us where it comes from: not the iron laws of economics, or the great forces of history, but specific policy choices made by powerful people who ignored every warning about the consequences of those choices. These are choices that can be undone. Enshittification is a Big Tech disassembly manual, a road map for the seizure of the means of computation. It is a diagnosis, and it is a cure.
Keeping in mind that Doctorow is a self-described leftist crank, I find some hope in his rebellious policy ideas. His accounts match my lived experience pretty well, and help me understand the politicians and policies that shaped it.
For oss som har fulgt Doctorows blogg og hørt en og annen forelesning eller intervju de siste årene er det ikke mye i denne boken som er nytt. Det er slik han jobber. Han er veldig produktiv og det er tydelig at skriveprosessen er en måte å tenke på. Det leder til at han ofte gjentar seg selv, på godt og ondt. Leser man noen få tekster får man fort med seg de viktige poengene og man kan lett velge en måte å motta det på som funker bra for en selv.
Når jeg først oppdaget Doctorow i tiden før Little Brother kom ut (jeg tror det første jeg leste av ham var Eastern Standard Tribe) konsumerte jeg alt jeg kom over. Det var ofte både engasjerende og insiktsfullt, men det var lett å bli litt lei. Det han skriver er fortsatt innsiktsfullt i dag, men jeg har aktivt …
For oss som har fulgt Doctorows blogg og hørt en og annen forelesning eller intervju de siste årene er det ikke mye i denne boken som er nytt. Det er slik han jobber. Han er veldig produktiv og det er tydelig at skriveprosessen er en måte å tenke på. Det leder til at han ofte gjentar seg selv, på godt og ondt. Leser man noen få tekster får man fort med seg de viktige poengene og man kan lett velge en måte å motta det på som funker bra for en selv.
Når jeg først oppdaget Doctorow i tiden før Little Brother kom ut (jeg tror det første jeg leste av ham var Eastern Standard Tribe) konsumerte jeg alt jeg kom over. Det var ofte både engasjerende og insiktsfullt, men det var lett å bli litt lei. Det han skriver er fortsatt innsiktsfullt i dag, men jeg har aktivt valgt og ikke lese bloggen hans, men leser enkeltinnlegg når jeg får dem anbefalt. Det blir passe doser.
Enshittification-begrepet er et som Doctorow har blitt kjent for langt utenfor sin egen leserkrets. For noen få dager siden lanserte Forbrukerombudet en rapport om digitale tjenester, i stor grad basert på Doctorows begrepsapparat og arbeid, men en tilhørende sketsj som har gått på rundgang i alle fall de sosiale mediene jeg henger på.
Boka gir en bra gjennomgang av Enshittification-prosessen, med noen konkrete eksempler; for så å legge fram et argument for hvordan dette har oppstått som en resultat av den mangelfulle usa-amerikanske konkurranselovgivinga. Som andre har skrevet er nok denne delen mindre intressant for den som ikke er interessert i detaljene i usaisk politikk, men delen er viktig for å kunne dra de lange linjene mellom problemet og løsningen.
Jeg synes bokens store styrke ligger i hvordan Doctorow aldri legger ansvar på oss som konsumenter. Vi er ikke der vi er fordi at vi har valgt feil tjenester eller feil programvare, men fordi vi har å gjøre med store monopolister. Løsningen ligger således i lovgiving, men også i kollektiv handling gjennom fagforeninger og forbrukerorganisasjoner.
Les boka. Argumentet er insiktsfullt og gjennomtenkt, og har du lest deler av argumentet andre steder gjør det ingenting. Det meste kommer du å kjenne igjen, men her er det samlet på ett og samme sted, og noe mindre satt på spissen enn i hans kortere tekster (han er mindre raljant, kanskje. Jeg liker den raljante Doctorow, men den kan i blant komme litt i veien).
If you remember the good internet and see this POS we use today, you can use this guide to what happened and how to change it.
The stories are clear and easy to understand, precise and full of the right heat about what was stolen and how, what can change and how.
This is the book to give to normies about what’s been done to them.
There are plenty of reviews of this book so go read one of those instead.
This book helps to explain why almost everything on the internet---and, more generally, our capitalist world---is getting worse. There are things that can be done about it but I'm not sure that there is the political will in the world to make it happen.
There are plenty of reviews of this book so go read one of those instead.
This book helps to explain why almost everything on the internet---and, more generally, our capitalist world---is getting worse. There are things that can be done about it but I'm not sure that there is the political will in the world to make it happen.
I felt it was a rather middle of the road collection of essays. I'm enjoying "The AI Con" much more.
I felt it was a rather middle of the road collection of essays. I'm enjoying "The AI Con" much more.
I don't care much for Doctorow's fiction but he has a knack to explain complicated things clearly. And this is true here, as he explains all the ways we got to our enshittified stated. As importantly, the last part of the book is dedicated to potential solutions. 4 stars instead of 5 because the idea that Trump might have an "anti-trust agenda" is laughable.
I don't care much for Doctorow's fiction but he has a knack to explain complicated things clearly. And this is true here, as he explains all the ways we got to our enshittified stated. As importantly, the last part of the book is dedicated to potential solutions. 4 stars instead of 5 because the idea that Trump might have an "anti-trust agenda" is laughable.
This is an extremely enjoyable read, and as a popular account that loosely sketches the causes of enshittification it stands up. However, Doctorow often uses a scan of news articles instead of deep historical or empirical research, with a variety of claims made without any proof beyond vibes to back them up. His biases are also on full display here but masquerading as fact - he clearly really likes tech workers, absolving them of all responsibility for many of the trends in the industry. He could be correct! But beyond his individual, subjective observations he brings no other proof to the party. Overall, this is a decent book on an important topic, but it is easily refutable in its current form and feels like a missed opportunity.
Enshittification has become an easy way to describe how tech goes bad, but Doctorow has done the work of backing up that wonderful new word he added to our lexicon with a framework and survey of tech's history to flesh it out. He provides a path forward to reverse Enshittification and his focus on coalition building is a key part of that. This book is for both veterans in the fight against Enshittification and those just now recognizing how bad things have gotten.
Enshittification has become an easy way to describe how tech goes bad, but Doctorow has done the work of backing up that wonderful new word he added to our lexicon with a framework and survey of tech's history to flesh it out. He provides a path forward to reverse Enshittification and his focus on coalition building is a key part of that. This book is for both veterans in the fight against Enshittification and those just now recognizing how bad things have gotten.
