Adam reviewed Shikasta by Doris Lessing
Review of 'Shikasta ' on 'Goodreads'
2 stars
I'm about 2/3 through this book and I doubt that I'll finish it. I like the idea of it, but there were many aspects of it which I had difficulties accepting.
The reports that together make up most of the book don't feel authentic to me. Many of the central ideas in the book are explained through the reports as if introduced for the first time to whoever reads them. I found this a bit clumsy, wouldn't it be reasonable to assume that the basics of canopean society should be familiar to whoever reads these reports? E.g. the introduction of the SOWF which is central to the Canopean colonization process is introduced in a way that assumes that Canopeans are unfamiliar with it. Furthermore, the author explains that there is no proper word for the SOWF, which I'd assume that a civilization, which is entirely built up around the concept, …
I'm about 2/3 through this book and I doubt that I'll finish it. I like the idea of it, but there were many aspects of it which I had difficulties accepting.
The reports that together make up most of the book don't feel authentic to me. Many of the central ideas in the book are explained through the reports as if introduced for the first time to whoever reads them. I found this a bit clumsy, wouldn't it be reasonable to assume that the basics of canopean society should be familiar to whoever reads these reports? E.g. the introduction of the SOWF which is central to the Canopean colonization process is introduced in a way that assumes that Canopeans are unfamiliar with it. Furthermore, the author explains that there is no proper word for the SOWF, which I'd assume that a civilization, which is entirely built up around the concept, should have a word for.
I also found it strange how the envoys go to such length to use neutral names of places and time periods for almost everything, but they have no problem using the Shikastan names of world war I and II to help the reader pin point the time in history. The only time that the Canopean name of this timeperiod is used, is when it is first introduced, after which all envoys revert to using the Shikastan name in their reports. Everything else uses the clumsy Canopean nomenclature.
I also had a problem grasping what was the point of many of the reports. The strange mix of explaining what happens on a global scale (including the awkward zone 6) with a few brief descriptions of some individuals.
The book does manage to reproduce the dryness of typical official reports, so I guess that's something.