Jorgen reviewed The Scar by China Miéville
an argument with the genre
3 stars
This is nothing like Perdido Street Station; the story meaners and never entirely comes together. He half explores a lot of ideas here but leans a bit too much on the mysterious side with a lot of it to actually have them come through? I don't know if the disagreements being fought out with the genre here are holding the story back because miéville hasn't finished his thoughts enough to articulate them into a persuasive narrative formulation, or whether he has finished them and is a bit too ready to move on. It is, of course, more bas lag, if the story not entirely coming together doesn't put you off.
This is nothing like Perdido Street Station; the story meaners and never entirely comes together. He half explores a lot of ideas here but leans a bit too much on the mysterious side with a lot of it to actually have them come through? I don't know if the disagreements being fought out with the genre here are holding the story back because miéville hasn't finished his thoughts enough to articulate them into a persuasive narrative formulation, or whether he has finished them and is a bit too ready to move on. It is, of course, more bas lag, if the story not entirely coming together doesn't put you off.