Amber Herbert reviewed Trace Elements by Ada Palmer
More Pretentious and Bloated Than It Is Fascinating
2 stars
This collection of essays is for the reader and/or writer who nerds out about the many interpretations of genre and craft as it pertains to science fiction and fantasy. It's also for those seeking reading recommendations and writing pointers from established authors in genre fiction. This collection is more pretentious and bloated than it is fascinating (and I say that as someone with a degree in English lit and an adoration for criticism). Quite a few of the essays were circular, repetitive, or lacking the depth Walton and Palmer wished to inject them with. All in all, every piece would have been more effective if read in its original (and separate) publication.
Thank you to Tor and NetGalley for the advanced copy.
This collection of essays is for the reader and/or writer who nerds out about the many interpretations of genre and craft as it pertains to science fiction and fantasy. It's also for those seeking reading recommendations and writing pointers from established authors in genre fiction. This collection is more pretentious and bloated than it is fascinating (and I say that as someone with a degree in English lit and an adoration for criticism). Quite a few of the essays were circular, repetitive, or lacking the depth Walton and Palmer wished to inject them with. All in all, every piece would have been more effective if read in its original (and separate) publication.
Thank you to Tor and NetGalley for the advanced copy.